In youth sports there is a prevailing culture of more, more, more. Far too often youth sports clubs rely on a brute force volume approach. This is a lazy option for both the coach and athlete. It is true that consistency is important. It is also true that progress is the result of doing the right things in the right way over an extended period of time. But when we become fixated on logging more repetitions we overlook the fact that practice hours are not equal. 100 hours of monotonous practice and mindless training is not equivalent to the same amount of time spent in quality practice and preparation where the athlete is highly engaged. Moreover, athlete development often requires something different rather than simply doing more of the same.
The push to do more is a big part of what is driving early specialisation and the additional hazards that entails. Participating in organised sport increasingly involves significant commitment even at younger ages. Attending multiple weekly practices for a single sport leaves little room for anything else. Practices are also now extending through more months of the year, crowding out opportunities to participate in other sports at other times in the year. This is compounded by push to take part in off-season camps and all the extras that are offered year-round.
More is not necessarily better. Doing more often comes with serious costs that can derail things entirely. Much of the burn out and the injury epidemic plaguing youth sport is a result of too much too soon, or rather, too much of the same thing too soon.
The Golden Mean described by Aristotle refers to the sweet spot that exists between too little at one extreme and too much at the other. This principle very much applies to sports practice and physical training. There are various times in the journey and indeed in the year when less is more. In general it is better to err on the side of being undercooked rather than pushing it to the point where athletes break down. This is particularly the case when we are talking about kids who are still growing and maturing.
Those of us who advocate for moderation need to acknowledge that this is not an appealing message. The merits must be sold to motivated kids who are striving to progress. Something that should help to get parents on board is that we can clearly demonstrate that excessive practice volumes significantly increase injuries among young athletes, especially during vulnerable periods in their growth and maturation. It is also evident that suffering such injuries will negatively impact their prospects of progressing in the sport.
All the same, asking kids to do less will continue to fall on deaf ears if they perceive that they will fall behind as a result. To overcome this we need to offer some assurance that their development will not suffer. Practically this means proposing strategies and practical solutions to boost the effectiveness and efficiency of practices, such that they can achieve the same output with more modest input. Central to this switch in mindset is shifting the emphasis from quantity to quality, such that we can do more with less and improve the return on time invested. Rather than simply logging hours, the mission becomes accumulating high quality repetitions over time.
All of this is part of a general approach that we might call careful coaching. Our primary concern should be making sure what we are doing is actually serving the young athlete and their development both in the short term and over the long term. This is akin to the Hippocratic oath - first do no harm. As coaches we should strive to be maximally helpful and minimally harmful. This requires judgement and wisdom. However, a key principle is seeking to maximise the quality of practice rather than simply adding more.
Restricting the number of practices and hours spent per week forces us to think about how we can get more out of the time spent. Practically, this depends on contributions from both the coach and the young athlete. Naturally the coach has a big role, given that the quality of practices depends on the design, content and delivery of practices. Equally, much also depends on the athlete. Improving the effectiveness and efficiency of practices requires the athlete to be properly prepared, ensuring they harness their full mental and physical resources during the session and spending time afterwards to reflect on the session and consolidate learning.
Parents are also a crucial part of this endeavour. Often the impetus to do more and the rush to specialise early in service of that comes from the young athlete themselves. We are capable of thinking on a longer time horizon, which is something that kids struggle with, so this is an area where we can offer valuable perspective. We are in a stronger position to resist the push to do more and make wiser judgements about what will best serve the young athlete’s interests over the long term.
Aside from reducing the risk of overuse injury, exercising moderation is a good way to preserve enthusiasm and encourage commitment. Effectively we should leave them wanting more. A prime example is taking time off during the year. Rather than participating in camps and other extras during the off-season, even the most motivated kids benefit from having time away from the sport. Not only will this allow them to return recharged and refreshed, but importantly this provides scope to participate in different sport across the year, which also serves their long-term development.


